Bumped

At my daughter’s birthday party last year it hit me: independent chairpersons at vivas fulfil the same function as bumpers at bowling alleys.

…let me explain!

There are regulations that underpin viva experiences. There are general expectations and a culture of examination. Academics receive training when they agree to take on thesis examination responsibilities but still might need additional support.

This is one of the purposes of an independent chair. They’re not an examiner at the viva, they’re there to provide support as needed – perhaps a little direction if required. A bumper in a bowling alley does the same thing: it doesn’t guarantee that anyone bowling scores a strike; they help guide the ball to where it needs to be.

The bowling ball is the general discussion in the viva: it can go off target but if necessary the bumpers at the sides will help it back on track.

Independent chairpersons help vivas go well. That’s the only reason they’re there. Not having one isn’t negative though: regulations, training and experience can help your examiners do the right thing.

Check your institution’s regulations to see when and why you might have an independent chair and check your circumstances to see particularly if you will.