Natural Asks

The PhD journey is often described as a journey into the unknown – and one that you make alone. This feeling often carries over to the viva and viva prep too but it’s actually natural to ask others for help along the way.

  • It’s natural to ask friends and colleagues about their viva experiences to get a sense of what goes on at vivas. It’s natural to ask for practical support from them if they have specific knowledge to help you.
  • It’s natural to ask your supervisor for help. It’s natural to ask your institution for assistance if you need to know more about the viva process or if you need an adjustment to that process.
  • It’s natural for you to ask questions of your examiners at the viva. They might be there to examine you but you can still ask questions for clarity, ask for their opinion and ask for breaks when you need them. The viva is a discussion not an interrogation.

It’s your PhD and your viva but you are surrounded by people who can help in many, many ways. It’s natural to ask questions for help.

Decorated

Thesis annotation is a helpful step in the viva prep process. It helps you to focus on your thesis while you prepare and creates a more helpful resource to use at your viva.

There’s plenty of space on every page to add notes, circle or highlight text, underline passages and stick in sticky notes. There’s plenty of space for you to make your thesis exactly what you need it to be.

There’s plenty of space to express yourself too.

I’ve been thinking about annotation for a long time but recently it’s occurred to me that annotation offers a space for art too. The wide margins and borders have room for decorations that help you enjoy your thesis more.

A little doodle can be fun and indicate the start of an important section. A hand-drawn warning sign can alert you to a key point (or a contentious one). A smiley face can remind you that everything is going to be OK.

Annotation and decoration. I’ll be thinking about this more in future to see how these ideas play a part in getting ready for the viva. However you approach it, remember that the most important aspect of this is to make your thesis as useful as possible for you at your viva.

What do you need?

Spork

Every viva is a spork, something between one thing and another.

Let me explain:

  • A viva exists, in part, on various scales: long or short; relaxed or formal; easy or challenging.
  • Some viva aspects have binary or fixed options: in-person, online or hybrid; two or three or more examiners; supervisor present or not.
  • Any viva, unique, fits somewhere in this mass of possibilities.
  • Every viva will be similar and different to others.

Every viva is a spork – and, in particular, your viva is a spork, similar to others and all its own thing too.

My Little Theories

I’ve spent over fifteen years helping PhD candidates get ready for their vivas. As a result I’ve developed some little theories that I think apply to most (and maybe all) people with a viva in their future.

Every candidate knows one question that they don’t want to be asked at their viva. But as a result they know something that they can prepare for. They may or may not be asked that question but they can be ready for it.

Too many candidates believe that the viva has an equal chance of pass or fail. Broadly speaking, candidates do pass or fail at their viva – but it is substantially more likely for someone to pass than fail.

When candidates hear the phrase “defend your thesis” they think protect instead of defend. This is why so many candidates (mistakenly) imagine that their examiners are out to get them, tear their work apart and find problems.

Do any of these resonate?

And do you have any other beliefs about the viva that may need testing against reality?

Ready For The Unknown

There are lots of viva expectations. These follow regulations, stories of experiences and the culture of departments. Knowing about viva expectations gives you a sense of patterns and trends. You can know:

  • Roughly how long a viva takes;
  • What the tone is supposed to be like;
  • That there’s only a very, very small chance of failure;
  • What the process is like;
  • How you might feel;
  • How you could respond and engage with the discussion.

Doing prep and learning expectations means you’re ready for the reality of the viva as it happens.

You’re not rehearsing to follow a set plan for your viva – you’re making yourself ready for the unknown.

Prep Caution

The only caution I typically have on the subject of viva prep is to be careful about doing more than is needed so someone can guard against stress.

There’s a lot that one could do to prepare for the viva. The scope of some tasks could seem open-ended at first.

For example, thesis annotation provides the opportunity to potentially add lots of detail to every one of hundreds of pages. Do you need to? Probably not! But stress, worry, uncertainty and concern could lead you down the path of doing far more than is necessary (and possibly far more than is wise).

Similar thinking could steer the work of reading your thesis, considering questions, reviewing papers and so on.

So what could you do?

  • Ask around to see what others have done.
  • Read around to look for reasonable advice.
  • Consider your specific situation and needs.
  • Plan what you will do.

Set some boundaries for yourself so that you don’t do too much and can push back against any stress you might encounter from feeling like you need to do more.

3-2-1

Pick three papers or references that have been important for your PhD journey.

For each reference write a few sentences in response to these two questions:

  1. Why does this reference make a difference?
  2. How would you summarise it for someone else?

Finally, reflect a little more and select one paper of the three that you think is more important than the others. Reflect and write down why you think it matters more.

Before You Start Your Prep

Read the regulations.

Gather your resources.

Bookmark helpful information.

Talk to friends.

Talk to your supervisors.

Make a plan.

Check you have everything you need to do the work you need to do.

 

Viva prep is work but viva prep doesn’t have to be stressful. Think ahead, plan and set the tone that you want to follow as you get ready for the challenge of your viva.

Before you start make sure you are ready to start well.

One To Ten

A simple viva prep reflection task.

Write down a list of topics related to your viva and viva prep: examiners, your preparedness, knowledge of expectations, ability to respond to questions – these are all good starting points. You can probably think of far more specific topics directly related to your research and your situation.

Got your list? Then quickly, without thinking too much and going on instinct, rate each of your topics from one to ten. Ten is positive, one is negative and everything else is the scale in-between.

Now work down the list for each topic:

  • What’s the number?
  • What does that mean?
  • What do you need to do as a result?

A low number could require action to change how you feel. A high number requires action to maintain how you feel. Either way, you have a little nudge to action.

Two key questions for viva times: How are you doing? and What will you do?

Small Slices Of Prep

Do you know the maths technique called integration. It’s fun!

At the most basic level it can help someone figure the area of something marked out by the curve of an equation and some lines.

Simple text showing a basic graph with a marked area

Integration starts out simple and can get incredibly complex. One way to approximate the answer, getting close enough to be useful, is to realise that you could break the larger area into strips that look a lot like rectangles. If you can measure their heights you can calculate the little areas and add them up.

Revised graph with area broken down into smaller strips for calculation

Unless you need a perfect answer you don’t need integration to find the area under the curve (so long as you can measure the space). You can look and estimate. You can work out little strips, small slices of almost-rectangles that help you get close enough.

All of which is to say: don’t try to focus on all of your viva prep and decide if you’ve done enough.

Estimate. Look at the pieces of your prep. Consider the scale of all of the little things you’ve done. Don’t try and do the big calculation: the estimate is enough.

Small slices of prep, maybe a little each day between submission and the viva, is enough to help you be ready.

1 2 3 … 364