As the capability of AI services has grown over the last few years I’ve been asked more often about what I think about using AI to help viva prep. I’ve been thinking a lot over the last few months about how it could be useful. Here’s where I’m at so far.
Let’s start with a key point: good viva prep is always an active and engaged process.
To get ready for the viva a PhD candidate needs to think, consider and engage with their work. They need to read their thesis well, annotate it, create summaries and more. They need to rehearse with other people to prepare for the reality of being in the viva.
You could upload your thesis into your AI service of choice and ask for a summary – but the value of creating a summary is that YOU think and focus. It’s not simply about having a list of bullet points: YOU have to create them.
You could ask an AI service to prompt you with questions based on your thesis – but the value of being asked a question in rehearsal is that you respond to it in real time in the way that you would in the viva.
Put simply, the value of viva prep is that YOU do the work.
There are no common viva prep tasks or activities that I think can be directly helped or improved by having an AI in the loop. As you get ready you need to think a lot to benefit from the work. You can’t offload that to something else. You need to do the thinking.
I’m not anti-AI. I’ve used an AI service for over a year to help me curate the Viva Survivors Select series from the blog archives. It’s been helpful to ask an imperfect-but-enthusiastic digital intern to help me explore the 3000+ posts I’ve written – and it has got lots wrong while trying to help me and doesn’t always do as I ask. Services improve but limitations remain.
So let me add a small qualifier to what I think so far: given what I understand about AI services and how they generally work – and given what I know about viva prep from over fifteen years of hands-on work in this area supporting PhD candidates – I don’t currently think there is a good use case for AI in effective viva prep.
But who knows what the future will bring?